Understanding Habits and How to Make Them Stick

Josh Allen • January 29, 2023

Have you ever wondered why making new healthy habits stick (for the long term) is often challenging? The answer lies in understanding the anatomy of a habit and behavior change.


There are Three Layers to Behavior Change:


1) Outcome/What

This is the goal you want to accomplish. It could be to lose weight or even to read more.


2) Process/How 

This is how you will accomplish this new goal. This is the actual habit or the act of doing something that results in the desired outcome.


3) Identity/Why

This is the reason for doing something to accomplish your goal. Having a firm grasp on your why is the true secret to sticking with your habit. To learn more, continue reading below.


Outcome Based Habits


The usual way most of us approach goal setting is to identify the outcome, or the desired result we want and then determine how to make it happen. For example, if you want to gain muscle mass (the outcome) the way to make it happen is through resistance training, eating healthy and recovering well (the process). This leads to outcome based habits and is the usual way most people tackle their goals.


Oftentimes we have great intentions to reach our goals and set forth with our new habits and everything is great until we stop without our goals being achieved. The problem is that we were too fixated on the goal without having an appreciation for the why behind the goal. Without knowing your why and really believing in it, habits just won’t last long enough to reach your goal.


The problem with outcome based habits is that they are powered by willpower and self discipline. Both are important characteristics for any goal driven person especially in the early stages of forming habits in order to build some initial momentum. However, at some point, having to muster up the strength each day to continue with our habits becomes more draining than motivating and we stop. 


A great example of this is in the world of healthy eating. Most people take on healthy eating for a desired outcome like fat loss but after a short period of time, they stop because it is too hard to cook three meals a day or because they can no longer say no to foods they are trying to avoid. 


Most of us at some point in our lives have found ourselves quitting the healthy habits BUT if we understand identity based habits, we will be less likely to throw in the towel and quit those habits we need to keep in our lives.


Identity Based Habits


For our habits to endure the test of time so that we reach our goals, we must look at our habits being fueled by our identity and know the why behind what we are doing. In other words, we should ask ourselves the question: why are these goals (outcomes) important to me that them worth doing? Or put another way, how will these habits shape who I am and who I wish to be?


In the example of someone wanting to lose fat weight, the why could be to avoid medication or to be a positive example for their children. This helps that individual to formulate an identity for themselves that then fuels the habits that need to happen.


When we identify ourselves as being a better version of who we currently are, it changes the neural networks in our brain that make it easier for us to begin and maintain the habits towards that vision. Whatever your goal is, think about the type of person that has those goals and identify yourself as being that same type of person. 


By constantly reminding ourselves of the why and picturing ourselves as the person we wish to be, we rewire our brains to believe it is possible. This creates the mindset needed and with better mindset, we increase the  likelihood of maintaining the habits and processes required for the goals or outcomes to be achieved.


If you want to lose weight for example, identify yourself as a healthy person who eats nutritious food and exercises regularly. When you identify yourself as that type of person already, it helps make habits stick longer because the actual habits that healthy people do are not just habits but a lifestyle.

Create a Vision Board


Many successful people have vision boards in their home or offices. Vision boards can be a wall or bulletin board with pictures of future goals to motivate you. If you want to have a lean body, it could be a picture of the lean body you wish to have. If it is energy you seek, it could be a picture of someone on top of a mountain. 


Vision boards remind you of your goals, who you are and who you wish to become. They are reminders that can help you shape your identity and they provide a much more powerful fuel to maintain habits compared to will power and self discipline.


Final Thoughts


When people want to improve, they often do not consider identity change and focus on outcome based habits. They are less likely to reach their goals because outcome based habits require you to constantly exercise will power and self discipline which goes against who you are.


Identity based habits work because they help make the process become a lifestyle. When habits become lifestyle you reach your goals much easier.  Only when you believe your identity is connected with the process will the outcome be achieved. 


Looking for support to help you make your own healthy habits? Contact us about our 1on1 or Group Health Coaching programs.  See
HERE for more details.


RESOURCES


This article was inspired by Simon Sinek and James Clear. 

Simon Sinek - The Golden Circle

James Clear - Atomic Habits


Transformation Health Coaching - Sign Up Here!
By Nova Health Club February 2, 2026
See how Joe transformed his body, mindset and consistency to take his results the next level!
By Nova Health Club January 8, 2026
In this interview, Beth shares how she stayed motivated, how her mindset and nutrition changes contributed to her results, and how she plans to keep the momentum going into 2026.
By Nova Health Club December 2, 2025
Over the past year Dino has trained consistently, built mobility and strength across every major lift, and hit daily activity goals like 7-8k steps - even while navigating the difficult loss of his wife this past year.
By Nova Health Club October 31, 2025
Sarah has been training with Nova for just over a year and we chose her as our SuperNova for how she uses training and fitness to stay strong for what she loves most: skiing, surfing, and adventure.
By Josh Allen October 22, 2025
It's that time of year again where Halloween candy is everywhere - especially if you have children who are in the trick or treating age. We all know that candy is unhealthy and we are aware of sugar's detrimental effects on our health, from weight gain to cavities... But do you know the risks in eating Halloween candy that go beyond weight gain and cavities? While sugar is certainly a concern, other ingredients in many popular candies can chip away at your health and well-being. The Deceptive Allure of Halloween Treats While eating Halloween candy can be a nostalgic pleasure, the ingredients list tells a different story. I personally love Halloween but about 7 years ago I went clean and gave up Halloween candy for good because I learned it is much more than a sugar problem… Beyond sugar, are ingredients like hydrogenated oils, high-fructose corn syrup, artificial colors, titanium dioxide and common allergens like wheat, corn, dairy, and soy. These ingredients can wreak havoc on our bodies, leading to a host of negative health effects that most consumers overlook. Beware: 5 Ingredients in Halloween Candy With Negative Health Effects 1. Hydrogenated Oils: Hidden Fats Hydrogenated oils transform liquid oils into solid fats and enhance texture and shelf life. These trans fats are notorious for raising bad cholesterol levels, increasing the risk of heart disease and causing inflammation in the body. Look out for the word ‘Hydrogenated’ in candies like Skittles or Starburst 2. High-Fructose Corn Syrup (HFCS): A Sweet Sabotage HFCS is another frequent offender. It’s a cheap, sweet alternative to sugar that can lead to rapid spikes in blood sugar levels and cravings. Overconsumption of HFCS has been linked to obesity, insulin resistance and fatty liver disease. Many people consume HFCS without even realizing it. Candies like Oh Henry and other chocolate bars have HFCS. 3. Artificial Colors: A Rainbow of Risks The colors that make Halloween candy so visually appealing are often the result of artificial colorings like Red 40, Yellow 5 (Tartrazine), Yellow 6 (Sunset Yellow) and Blue 1. Studies have shown links between these artificial colors and hyperactivity in children, as well as allergic reactions as well. Here are some of your Halloween favorites with these colors: Skittles , Maynards , Sour Patch Kids , Jolly Rancher , Twizzlers , Starburst and M&M’s 4. Titanium Dioxide: The White Truth Titanium dioxide is used in many candies to enhance their whiteness and opacity. It is a detergent that damages your gut and decreases your gut microbiome. Any candy that has a white center, like Skittles is known to use this ingredient. 5. Allergens: Hidden Dangers for Sensitive Individuals Finally, we can’t forget the processed allergens like wheat, corn, dairy and soy in many candies like Mars or Snickers . Those who are highly allergic know to stay away from foods with these ingredients but what about the low grade allergic response that most people ignore? Hives, scratchy through, congestions, asthma, sneezing, itchy eyes and mild GI discomfort are all effects of these allergens. The Scary Reality Halloween is a fun time but we’ve really thrown in the towel when it comes to our health based on the things we are accepting as ok. We've created a society where we buy the cheapest, lowest quality candies to give to our children (and ourselves). Most, if not all of the mainstream candy companies produce products that are high in chemicals to preserve shelf life, to entice our eyeballs and to stimulate our brain to want more the moment it hits our palette. We've also bought into the idea that it's ok because it is just once a year... but the reality is that this food is everywhere all the time. If it was just one day on Oct 31 then sure - that could be ok, but most children are coming home with more than 10lbs of candy that they consume over the next 30 days. It’s no wonder why so many of us suffer with health issues including our children. Modern children are being diagnosed with more health problems than previous generations. Things like childhood depression/anxiety, food allergies, ADHD, autism, eczema and obesity are just some of the things we are seeing more of. Stay Vigilant and Read Labels Can we blame our poor health all on Halloween candy? Certainly not - it's more than just candy in October however the amount of candy with the above ingredients being consumed during Halloween and through the year is definitely a contributor. So when it comes to candy, watch out for the sugar but it’s time to wake up to the other ingredients that are damaging us. The best thing to do is read the labels and be aware of what you choose to consume. And hopefully in time we choose to buy 'treats' that are not filled with chemicals. Next year, choose to buy healthier options versus the mainstream candy we grew up with. Healthier Alternatives Here are some options to consider instead of the mainstream low quality garbage that we've been accustomed too: Chocolate Bars Unreal Coconut Bars : This company is on point with way healthier ingredients than the mainstream. They carry an assortment of candies beyond just the coconut bar (which is one of my faves). Granola Bars Made Good : You've probably seen this brand around in stores - specializing in gluten free healthier granola bars. Cookies Simple Mills : Making cookies and baked goods gluten free and with sweeteners that have a lower glycemic index than regular sugar (less of a blood sugar spike) Candies Smart Sweets : Candies without artificial colors and high sugar Lollipops & Jelly Beans YumEarth : W ithout artificial colors Water Enhancer (Vitamin C) Emergen-C : Something different from usual candy - Vitamin C drink crystals that are a much healthier option to candy and kids love em. There are more brands out there but you have to be on your toes when buying. Pay attention to brands, scrutinize the ingredient list and pay the extra money. Every dollar you spend is a vote - the more we vote for the better products for our health, the lower the cost will end up being in the future.
By Josh Allen October 22, 2025
Having trouble controlling the intake of Halloween candy? Unless you are a disciplined ninja or equipped with helpful restraint tactics, you end up eating too much of this low quality, highly processed junk food. If you are someone with a sweet tooth then you are in luck! Here are 5 tactics that will help you avoid eating too much (if any) candy this Halloween. 1)Don’t Skip Meals or Snacks Skipping meals and snacks creates stress on your body and a stressed body is more likely to have sugar cravings. Self control becomes extremely difficult when you're underfed. If candy appears it is much harder to resist because your body is lacking energy, vitamins and minerals. If you eat a solid meal along with healthy snacks throughout the day (ie: protein shake, apple and almonds) I guarantee that it will be hard to eat candy. 2)Eat Enough Protein On the heels of not skipping meals, make sure each meal has enough protein. Meals that are low in protein mean that they are higher in carbs. As a result you will deal with blood sugar dips and greater hunger, weakening your resistance to candy. How much protein? This differs between people but generally you aim to have at least 0.8 grams of protein per pound of ideal body weight. The more active you are, the more protein you will require. 3)Stay Hydrated Being dehydrated will make you feel hungry even when you are not actually hungry. As a result you are more likely to have the urge to grab a sweet from the candy bowl. The simple solution is to just drink enough water throughout the day. How much water? Click here to download your All About Water PDF. 4)Say It Out Loud Often we eat candy without thinking. It is not uncommon to have 5 or 6 candies before you become mindful of what you are doing. By then it’s too late. This may sound strange but as you are picking up the candy - say out loud “I am going to eat this candy” (even if no one is around). This helps you become more aware of your actions, encourages mindfulness, and engages your logical mind. 5)Educate Yourself The scary truth is that mainstream Halloween candy is some of the worst food you can put into your body. Most of these candies contain highly inflammatory ingredients, allergens, and toxins known to disrupt everything from the gut microbiome to DNA, potentially contributing to ADHD symptoms and triggering allergies… And that’s without commenting on the effects of sugar that most of us already are aware of. Eating certain candies can be just as bad as smoking a cigarette! Give these tactics a try - they should help you to say no to Halloween junk food this year. If you are still having trouble, you can attempt a ‘clean sweep’ by throwing it all into the garbage… If you still have a sweet craving, have some dark chocolate or walk to the best bakery in town and buy yourself a $10 chocolate croissant :) Happy (Healthy) Halloween!
By Nova Health Club September 8, 2025
Andrew has been a Nova member for 9 years. One of his long standing goals was to do his first triathlon. He has been working towards this for years and just at the end of August he did it!
By Josh Allen August 7, 2025
If you're doing all the “right things” — working out, eating clean, trying to stay consistent — but still struggling with stubborn belly fat, low energy and slow results, you’re not alone.
By Nova Health Club August 1, 2025
Tanya’s dedication to rebuilding her health after surgery offers valuable lessons and perspective for anyone facing setbacks.
Show More